With brands exploring local botanicals, new serves and international markets, the category is beginning to look beyond its traditional relationship with gin. 

It’s difficult to look at the tonic category without also mentioning the G&T. The serve has long been one of the trade’s most reliable, helping to bolster tonic into an established category in its own right. However, as the market matures, the role of tonic is changing. Rather than simply accompanying an interesting gin, consumers are looking to the mixer itself to bring flavour and a sense of storytelling to the glass.

“The gin market in general has taken a bit of a dip in the craft side of things, people are watching what they spend, so buying more mainstream gins and adding a craft tonic water,” says Chris Wium, co-founder of South African tonic and mixers brand Barker & Quin. “If you have a London dry gin and add flavours through tonic it completely transforms the drink. It gives you a new dynamic and flavour profile without spending too much on the gin.”

That is particularly evident in the country, where Wium says the demand for more sophisticated mixers is evolving alongside a return to established mainstream gin brands.

“I think the gin and tonic market in South Africa is still very prevalent, but not on the craft side so much. The London Dry gins, Bombay Sapphire, Gordon’s, the powerhouse gins, there’s a big drive towards creating a better mixer to go with these.”

For Barker & Quin, that opportunity has also meant looking closer to home for flavour inspiration. The brand’s range utilises local botanicals and ingredients, with the idea of offering something other than the conventional tonic profile.

“We set out to find natural spring water and a natural ingredients supply company. Once we launched the Indian tonic back in August 2016 it quickly sold out and people started asking for a light version. Off that people asked for more flavours and we started looking at local botanicals and locally interesting flavours. We found hibiscus was a very popular tea people were drinking all over Africa so we started with hibiscus and found it very accommodating to rose-infused gins and flowery gins. Then we went on by looking at more South African flavours and popular fruit. The honeybush is a very popular local botanical and we’ve added a bit of orange to bring out the flavour of the honeybush. We never really wanted to copy anything on the world market,” adds Wium.

Also based in South Africa, Fitch & Leedes’ range includes a classic Indian tonic with variants such as Pink (rose and cucumber), Grapefruit and Dry Lemon. For Dave Morton, founder of its UK arm and chief executive of Bespoke Beverages, one of the most interesting shifts is that “tonic is becoming less narrowly defined by the traditional G&T occasion”. He adds: “Gin remains enormously important, but consumers are increasingly looking for more choice in flavour, more versatility across different spirits and more sophisticated drinking options when they are moderating or choosing not to drink alcohol.

“What I particularly love about our range is that the flavours have a purpose. It isn’t innovation simply for the sake of adding another SKU. Different profiles allow the mixer to complement rather than overpower the spirit while also giving people more interesting choices across alcoholic and non-alcoholic occasions. 

The G&T is absolutely still a major driver, and I don’t think we should underestimate its importance. But while gin helped create the premium tonic category, I don’t think gin has to define its future,” Morton continues. 

EXPANDING THE OPPORTUNITY 

For brands looking to capitalise on the appetite for flavour innovation, distribution remains a significant hurdle, particularly for South African producers wanting to compete in international markets alongside much larger global brands.

“The biggest challenge I would say is distribution worldwide,” says Wium. “It’s a very big thing to get tonic waters from South Africa into the international market. We recently started bottling our products in Hungary which is a very good hub in eastern Europe to get the product into the European market. Pre-Covid we were in about 32 markets, that tapered down a lot after Covid and now we’re in five or six countries in Europe, as well as North America, Africa and islands like Mauritius and the Maldives. We’re now starting to re-look at our distribution options in Australia. But there’s a lot of challenges from corporate companies. It’s very tricky to compete with these big powerhouses in terms of pricing and distribution but I think people are looking for something different and that’s what we offer,” says Wium.

“In the Far East they’re just beginning to touch on gin and tonic. I’ve had requests in Taiwan because they don’t get Fever-Tree there or Schweppes, so that’s something we’re exploring. People are buying down a bit in terms of expensive gins, tequilas, vodkas, but they’re relying on mixers to make it a bit more affordable and approachable,” Wium continues.

For Morton, the category is still evolving. “I think the definition of the category will continue to broaden. Classic tonic will remain important, but alongside it we will see more purposeful flavour development, lower-sugar choices and mixers designed around a wider range of spirits and drinking occasions.

“Our European distributors and retailers think moderation presents a very significant opportunity. Choosing not to drink alcohol on a particular occasion does not mean consumers suddenly stop wanting flavour, ritual, presentation or the experience of having a well-made adult drink. Premium mixers are particularly well placed to meet that need,” Morton continues.

“I think the most successful innovation will therefore be less about novelty for novelty’s sake and more about creating mixers that genuinely suit a particular spirit, serve or occasion. In short, the first era of premium tonic was driven largely by the premiumisation of gin. The next may be driven by the premiumisation of the drinking occasion itself.” 

With talk of tonic finding its way without the G&T, the serve remains at the heart of the category. However, the role of the mixer is changing as consumers become more selective about what they spend and more interested in flavour.